Home Articles Erotic Humor by Donald H. Gilmore Phd.
Erotic Humor by Donald H. Gilmore Phd.

Erotic humor is a field unto itself, and before we begin our examination of the rather bizarre world of the eight-page comics let's cover some of the basic factors involved in the process of the creation of these outrageous satires.

First the mechanics. The eight pagers were what is known as "back dOor" publications, created, printed and sold on an informal, underground basis. Although a "distributor" or vendor occasionally ran into legal problems with local authorities, researchers, including at least two major government agencies, have been unable to trace either the artists or the printers of a majority of these comics. What facts are available are inconclusive.

The authorities, for instance, raided a warehouse in Philadelphia in 1935 and confiscated "thousands" of these "pornographic" comic booklets. The shipment was destined for a local "distributor" in Philadelphia and had its origin in Cleveland, Ohio. But when the Cleveland authorities tried to locate the shipper, they ran into a blank wall.

A similar shipment was seized in Detroit in January of 1936, and again the origin was Cleveland, Ohio. And again the authorities in Cleveland were unable to trace the shipper.

But just when Cleveland was beginning to look like the center of the eight-page comics, a large shipment was seized in Los Angeles, California. This time the origin was Chicago. And when the authorities traced the Chicago address they found a building which handled shipments in transit from New York! Natural­ly the New York authorities ran into a blank wall when they attempted to trace the origin of shipment in their city.

In the period between 1935 and 1939 a total of sixteen raids took place on shipments of the eight-page comics. The points of origin of shipment included Allentown, Pennsylvania; Bristol, Tennessee; Cleveland, Ohio; Detroit, Michigan; Des Moines, Iowa; Gary, Indiana; Milwaukee, Wisconsin and New York City. In not one of these raids and seizures, which apparently involved several hundred thousand eight pagers, was an arrest made. The authorities were not only unable to trace the shippers, they could not locate the recipients. The shipments were either lost or broken and the "distributors" (probably on tips) did not show up to claim their merchandise.

During the research for this series the author located a man who distributed eight pagers during the thirties and early forties. Today this man owns and operates a successful dry cleaning business, but he was willing to discuss candidly his earlier distribution of erotic comics. The following excerpts from the author's interview with this man give us some insight into how the eight pagers were handled.

"... It was a screwy business, believe me. A real hip pocket operation ... And it was feast or famine. One minute I'd have a big shipment and make a pile, then I'd be begging for merchandise and starving...

"I had two suppliers, one in Chicago and the other in New York. Everything was strictly hush-hush. In those days, the eight pagers were hot stuff and you had to be careful... All I ever knew were their first names. The guy in New York was Jake, and the one in Chicago was a gal named Guilda. A German gal, I think ... I had two phone numbers for each of them. One was the office. At least it was the one I used to place orders and all. The other was an emergency number I was supposed to use if I couldn't get them at the office. It was a safe line, and if I had to call there I was just supposed to leave my first name and a number where I could be reached. Then they'd call me back later on ...

"... No, I never knew the name of the company. Just the first name and phone number. To be frank, I don't think there was any company. They just printed those things up in a basement somewhere and shipped them out whatever way they could ...

"... Well, it wasn't so much placing orders. I could sell every damned one of those I could get my hands on, so it was getting a supply that kept me busy. I think they must have printed about every three or four months because that's the way I'd get them; big shipments all at once and then nothing for three months or so. That's why I had two suppliers. One would ship one month and the other might ship six weeks later. When they both shipped at the same time, it was hell on me because I'd have to come up with the dough right away ...

"...Well, I'd get a call telling me they had a shipment ready for me. Neither one of them would ship C.O.D., so I had to send them a cashier's check made out to myself and signed off on the back. In a real emergency, they'd let me wire them the money, but they didn't like that because they'd have to give me a name to send it to ... Sure, I had an address, but they'd change it up all the time. Each time they called me about a shipment being ready, they'd give me an address to send the money to. That's what I meant when I said it was a real hip pocket operation ...

"... My cost varied, but usually it was between a dime and fifteen cents apiece. That's because I bought in quantity, between three and seven thousand copies at a crack. A couple of times I went as high as ten thousand when they'd give me that many. They didn't exactly ration shipments, but they knew just about how many a distributor could handle and that's all they'd set for him in their print run. I think they had me figured at about four thousand, because when I'd ask for more than that I'd have to do some arguing. And they had their own credit system. If a distributor couldn't come up with cash, they'd give his shipment to someone else. That was how I'd get extras now and then ...

"... Well, 'distributor' is a pretty fancy word. That's what they called me, but I was just a guy who sold the comics in an area. I didn't have dealers or anything like that, and I operated mostly on my own ... Businessmen and working men for the most part. I had a regular run in about seven cities, garages, a few factories, some office buildings. The only guys I had working for me were a couple of college kids. Between them, they'd dump a thousand or so every couple of months. I guess they sold them at the schools ... I'd sell them to the kids for forty cents and they'd get a buck for them ... I'd say that most of them I sold went for fifty cents, but in some places I could charge a buck and get away with it. I had one office where I used to get two bucks a copy, so I always saved them the best...

"I'd say when all was said and done, I'd pick up maybe a grand a month. But in the depression that was pretty big money. Some months I'd make maybe three grand, but then I'd dry out for a while because I couldn't get merchandise ...

"... No, I wasn't very big. I once met a guy who sold in New York and he was pushing about four thousand a month regular. And another guy in Kansas City used to sell more than that. The funny thing was, the more religious the community, the better the sales. I always did better in little towns. I guess those people weren't getting any action so they had to read about it... "

From everything the author has been able to learn, this man was a typical "distributor" among those handling the eight pagers in the thirties and forties. It was a relatively small, loosely organized, highly secretive business which yielded excellent mark-ups. The fact that there was no regular supply seems to be supported by the markings on a majority of the original eight-page comics. These markings, which indicate series and print runs, show that large numbers of these were produced in groups. Several collectors agree with the author that the publishers apparently waited until they had a number of different comics from the artists and then commissioned a gang run with a willing printer. This would explain the distribu­tor's statement that he could only purchase a new shipment every three or four months.

The interesting point here is that the eight pagers were not a product of the underworld, which was far too organized to do business in this manner. Instead, they appear to have been produced by a number of small, closely knit groups which sprang up in different parts of the United States. A close study of the originals indicates that different printing equipment and even different plates were used by the same publisher. There is additional evidence that the publishers were transient, moving from one city to another over a period of time. Apparently few found it profitable to own their own printing equipment and preferred to hire a printer or lease his presses for a week when they made their long runs.

At no point was any real effort made to put quality into the printing of the eight pagers. Several publishers attempted Jo add color by using small amounts of red on the covers, but these were limited to a few series in the entire history of the erotic comics. Sophisticated art, color and printing techniques such as we see in the currently popular Cunt and Snatch erotic comics were simply not necessary when the original eight pagers were produced.

The basic sales appeal, then, of the erotic comics of the thirties and forties was the content and not the packaging. And here we enter our discussion of erotic humor to understand the process involved in both the creation and appeal of this particular form of erotica.

A sense of humor is not universal in man, and humor itself is a highly subjective thing. What makes one person burst into gales of laughter may well leave the next man cold. Humor depends on many factors, among them situation, experience, conditioning and individual personality structure. And as the ability to appreciate humor varies, the ability to operate it is even more limited. All too few individuals possess this gift, and only a small percentage of those who do have it make any real use of it.

Sigmund Freud pointed out in his Wit and its Relation to the Unconscious: "Though wit-making is an excellent means of obtaining pleasure from the psychic process, we know that not all persons are equally able to make use of it. Wit-making is not at the disposal of all; in general there are but a few persons to whom one can point and say that they are witty. Here wit seems to be a special activity somewhere within the region of the old 'psychic faculties,' and this shows itself in its appearance as fairly independent of other faculties such as intelligence, fantasy, memory, etc."

An argument is often advanced here that fantasy is an integral part of wit, particularly in view of the fact that often humor is achieved through a given measure of in appropriateness, fantastic exaggeration or complete irrelevance. And when humor involves protest, which it so frequently does, there is a certain amount of intelligence involved in its creation and execution.

As any comedian will quickly attest, there is no set formula involved in the creation of successful wit. And many argue that its execution is as important as its creation. Be that as it may, there are certain basic ingredients found in the pattern of all humor. These vary according to situation, audience and the type of humor involved, yet unless basic formulas are followed the humor is often subject to failure.

It is important to remember here that successful humor depends on mass appeal. If there are one hundred in an audience and only two laugh at a humorous portrayal, the humor failed. Almost every human being will laugh at something, yet successful humor must appeal to a wide audience.

While this must be stated only in the most general terms, it is accepted that the most successful humor deals with real situations—albeit in an exaggerated or irrelevant form. And frequently this involves an exaggeration of reality. Within this same format, it has been found that the most successful forms of humor based on reality involve human beings. People like to laugh at people, which is another psychological pattern which we must simply accept rather than examine here. The point is that a joke about a computer making a mistake never has as wide an appeal as a joke about a human being making a mistake.

Accepting these two premises as basic to the successful humor syndrome, we can move into the field of erotic humor. Here we see one particular facet of the human being exploited for the purpose of wit, and there is certainly nothing new about combining eroticism with humor. Some of the earliest forms of eroticism combine humor with erotic portrayal (see Sex, Censorship and Pornography, Volume I). There are several basic reasons for this. First, sexual behavior in most societies has a certain amount of shock value, and this serves as a factor for exaggeration. But even more important is the fact that the more intimate the human activity, the greater the potential for humor. And certainly sex is a very intimate form of human behavior.

It is not meant to imply here that humor and eroticism go hand in hand. It is simply that one is compatible with the other. This is not only true from the aspect that every human being harbors some reservations about his or her sexual adequacy and ability, but also from the standpoint of social proscrip­tion which in the past tended to make any form of sexual behavior naughty. Thus the guilt anxiety attached to sex plays a part in both the creation and appeal of erotic humor.

This was particularly true in the Elizabethan period when humor was dominant in most erotic poetry. We also see it reflected in the broadly erotic and scatologic art of that period.

What is the secret to the combination of eroticism and humor? Freud once expressed the opinion that it is one of the fundamental desires of mankind to see the sexual exposed. His view was that this in itself was a sign of civilized development, the more primitive pleasure being that of touch. "... the smutty joke is

like the denudation of a person of the opposite sex, toward whom the joke is directed. Through the utterances of obscene words the person attacked is forced to picture the parts of the body in question, or the sexual act, and is shown that the aggressor himself pictures the same thing. There is no doubt that the original motive of the smutty joke was the pleasure of seeing the sexual displayed ..."

And we can immediately recognize that the factors which contribute to the creation also relate to the appeal. These processes are virtually identical.

Within the framework of this reasoning, then, we see that erotic humor is quite basic. It follows a strong desire in the psychology of man, exposing the sexual, and at the same time utilizes a fundamental formula of humor by portraying intimate life situations in detail. In erotic humor, however, the creator often explodes and magnifies the descriptions and feats of the principals completely out of the realm of reality. For the most part, and particularly in the erotic comics, this is simply a form of exaggeration—another ingredient of the humor formula.

Another important factor in the humor syndrome is that most humor is timely and not timeless. Like every form of art, humor reflects an era through both its form and theme. During the Second World War, for example, a joke about Adolf Hitler frequently met with mass appeal among his enemies. Today, a Hitler joke would be hard pressed to raise a chuckle in most quarters. While Shakespeare and a few immortals created humor which spanned the centuries, most humor is best viewed against its contemporary back­ground. This is particularly true with most satire and all protest humor, which depend almost entirely on given situations and conditions. For this humor is, after all, directed at a specific situation or condition.

With this in mind, we should take a brief look at the eras in which any particular form of humor was created. In the Elizabethan era, for instance, we had the beginnings of what would later be termed the "sexual revolution." We also had a highly romantic era in which poets flourished and artists approached their subjects with romantic interpretations.

The era of the eight pagers, however, was complete­ly different. More than almost any other art form, the erotic comics were a product of their time. They were and are a rather bizarre reflection of the thirties in the United States.



 


 

 

Free Joomla 1.5 Templates By Joomlashack